Posts

Showing posts with the label methods of historiogrophy and the data of sophistical connection demonstrate that the myth theory is not sufficient to explain the web of historical connection.

My Argument V in my Debate with Bowen: Web of Historicity

In this argument I will present three major sub points. The first deals with theoretical and methodological matters of historiography. The second with historical data, and the third unites the first two to show that the myther theory does not explain the historical data. A. Historical methods (1) The document, not the people, is the point. One chief principle sorely lacking in the discussion with mythers, is that historians start from the sources we have rather than criticizing that which we don't have. Historians don't base their conclusions upon the documents we lack but upon those we possess. What do the documents we have tell us? Don't worry about what they don't tell us. (Chitneis p39 discussing internal and external evidence. [1] ) The objection that we don't have anyone who knew Jesus personally writing about him (supposedly), is bunk. Start from what what the documents we do have tell us about him. Chitneis emphasizes internal and external aspects of ...