Posts

Showing posts with the label Luke-Acts

Did GosMark's Author Possibly Invent the Empty Tomb? (Nope 7 of 9)

PART 7: DISAPPEARING ACTS OF THE TOMB Part 1 of this series is way back here. Recently I've been looking at curious problems surrounding the empty tomb narratives in the Gospels and how they point away , in one or two categories I think quite decisively, from GosMark's having invented the empty tomb. But enough about the Gospel accounts. How about some disappearing Acts? No, not the Ascension account in Acts. I'm talking about the tomb! 7.) The canonical book of Acts is quite notable, not only for having some seriously primitive(-seeming) language in talking about the risen Jesus, but in a lack of detail during reported preaching about the empty tomb. And by a lack of detail, I mean almost no mention of the tomb at all! To begin with, it's important to notice, and to keep in mind, that regardless of whether Acts and GosLuke were written by the same guy, and regardless of any redactional theories of Acts' composition; whoever put Acts together in its fina...

Craig Keener's Case for the Historical Jesus, Part II

In the previous post in this series I presented some quotes from Craig Keener's recent book, The Historical Jesus of the Gospels, relevant to some general questions about the nature of the Gospels. In this post I include quotes from Keener on Luke-Acts in particular. I will continue to follow the Q&A format. Why should we think that Luke-Acts is historical and strives to present an accurate account of the beginning of Christianity? Various factors support the thesis that Luke conceives of his project as primarily a history. Unlike a novel, Luke uses sources abundantly in his first volume (usually agreed to be at least Mark and "Q") and presumably in his second volume as well, although we cannot distinguish the sources clearly in Acts. Luke's claim to investigate or have close acquaintance with his information (Lk 1:3) fits historical works, and his occasional use of the first-person plural (e.g., Acts 16:10) emphasizes the involvement considered ideal for a good ...

Reading Luke's Preface Again: Historiography or Biography?

In my online article on Acts, I conclude that " Acts stands out as a work of ancient history. " The genre of Luke, however, can be somewhat more elusive. The preface and literary relationship with Acts count strongly in favor of classifying it as ancient history, but the focus on Jesus and other features, such as the recounting of his lineage, are clear biographical elements. David Aune classifies Luke as ancient historiography for the aforementioned reasons and his inclination to keep their genre unified. Craig Keener, on the other hand, see no problem in classifying Luke as biography and Acts as history. Further, no assessment would be complete without recounting Richard Burridge's analysis of the Synoptics, including Luke, and his conclusion that they all fall within the genre of biography. Although acknowledging the strong biographical focus on Luke, I lean towards classifying it as ancient historiography. As I explained in an early CADRE post , "Acts is...

Does Ignatius Demonstrate Reliance on the Acts of the Apostles?

I recently discussed whether Ignatius relied on Paul’s letter to the Ephesians when he wrote his own letters. During my review of the letters and secondary literature, I revisited the issue of Ignatius’s awareness of Luke-Acts. I had previously touched on this issue in my article about the the Acts of the Apostles and concluded that the points of contact were insufficient to establish awareness of Luke or Acts. Upon further review, I believe the issue deserves more in-depth discussion and a stronger case for Ignatius’ dependence on Luke-Acts can be made. Knowledge of Paul’s Connection with Ephesus The most important piece of evidence that prompted my review of this issue was Ignatius’ reference to the Ephesian Church and Paul’s martyrdom. You are a passageway for those slain for God; you are fellow initiates with Paul, the holy one who received a testimony and proved worthy of all fortune. When I attain to God, may I be found in his footsteps, this one who mentions you in every...

Genre, On the Life of Moses, and Luke-Acts

In a previous post , I discussed the difference a genre can make by focusing on Philo's On the Life of Moses ( OLM ). Although usually adopting a creative allegorical approach to Jewish scripture, in OLM Philo adopts a relatively straightforward biographical approach to the life of Moses. He makes relatively faithful use of the Old Testament and traditions of his people. While reading OLM , I was struck by the similarities in many of its features with Luke-Acts . I will begin with the general similarities and then focus in more detail on the similarities of the works' prefaces. General Features On the Life of Moses and Luke-Acts are of comparable length, filling two scrolls. OLM is around 32,000 words long and Luke-Acts is around 37,700 words long. On the Life of Moses and Luke-Acts are both Greco-Jewish works. Their audiences were predominantly Hellenized readers, though possessing an interest in the Jewish faith. Related to the Jewish aspects of both writings is ...

The Unity of Luke-Acts

Modern scholarship accepts that the Gospel of Luke and the Acts of the Apostles were written by the same author. But a more subtle question is whether that author started out to write one work in two volumes or if the idea of writing Acts occurred to him after finishing his Gospel. It does not settle the question that Acts obviously harkens back to the themes and style of Luke, because so would an unanticipated sequel or the second volume of a two volume work. There are, however, features of Luke which indicate that its author all along planned on writing a sequel. First, the two prefaces to Luke-Acts indicate that Acts is the second volume of a two-volume literary effort, not just a sequel. Acts begins with a ‘secondary prologue,’ a device used for introducing new segments to works consisting of more than one book. Luke’s, of course, was a two-volume work: and Luke 1:1-4 is the ‘primary preface’ for his entire work, including Acts. In Hellenistic literature a secondary preface u...
Could There Have Been An Earlier Census? -- Further Thoughts on Luke's Nativity Even if Luke is properly translated to refer to a registration which occurred before the famous one under Quirinius, it is argued that it is impossible that there was any census in Judea prior to the one under Quirinius. This is mostly an argument from silence based on the fact that -- other than Luke's reference -- there are no direct mentions of any such census. Since arguments from silence are problematic, especially when -- as here -- our records and history are incomplete, critics attempt to bolster this argument by arguing that there were no census' in client-kingdoms under Roman rule. That is, though under the control of Rome, Rome let a local king run the province. At the time of Jesus’ birth, that king was King Herod. However, there are at least two responses to this argument. First that Herod conducted his own system and second that Rome ordered such a census be conducted. I wil...
Luke, the Census, and Quirinius: A Matter of Translation Introducing the Issue One of the more well-known criticisms of the Gospel of Luke’s infancy narratives is that it puts the census (also called a “registration”), that caused Joseph and Mary to travel to Bethlehem, at the wrong time. Most versions translate Luke 2:1 along the lines of the New Revised Standard Version: Luke 2:2: This was the first registration and was taken while Quirinius was governor of Syria. The problem is that the registration that occurred under Quirinius took place in 6 AD, a few years after the reign of King Herod. But Luke places the birth of Jesus during the reign of King Herod, between 4-7 BC. The registration under Quirnius was significant because it signaled the beginning of direct Roman control over Judea. Prior to that time, King Herod – not a respected Jew, but also not a Roman – governed all of Israel as a client king of Rome. Not too long after he passed away, Judea came to be ruled directl...

When does Luke indicate Jesus was Born?

In his article on the Nativity in Luke, Richard Carrier argues that "It is beyond reasonable dispute that Luke dates the birth of Jesus to 6 A.D" and claims that he has surveyed "all the evidence both to this effect and against all known attempts to reconcile these authors." Of course, most historians do dispute such a late dating and believe that Luke places Jesus' birth prior to 3 BCE. Although Carrier does cover a lot of ground, I do not believe he has given adequate attention to the announcement narrative itself or Mary's encounter with Elizabeth the mother of John the Baptist. From those two accounts, it seems clear that Luke places Mary's conception very shortly after the announcement that she will conceive (which took place while Elizabeth was pregnant with John). The appearance of Gabriel to Mary announcing her pregnancy, as well as Mary's visit to her cousin (pregnant with John the Baptist) and finally the birth of John the Baptist, are al...